Wednesday, August 06, 2008

On engineers as founders of a start-up

I'm an engineer myself, by background and training, so I value logic and organization, and see those as being important tools for anyone, much less the founder of a start-up.

BUT...

I've worked in this area before, and have advised young entrepreneurs, and I can see weaknesses that engineers have. Not all engineers, of course, but I have them, and that's why I'm not a founder now myself, much as I might like to be.
  1. I've never had the breakthrough idea, the "killer app." Something that demonstrates breakthrough thinking. Like many others, I have had ideas that someone else has taken to market, but all that says is that a good idea springs up in multiple places all at once. History already tells us this. Engineers can solve problems, but a founder should have at least one breakthrough.
  2. I'm a skilled social networker, but I've never been good at seeking out and finding new contacts. I tend to stick myself out there and let them find me. Like raccoons can find peanut butter. LOL I think a founder should be the kind of person who can make contacts appear out of thin air.
  3. When I worked for a start-up, the founders tended to keep me away from investors, because I would tell the truth. It's not that the founders won't, but their priority among multiple truths is the one that will hopefully draw out financing. I might tell the investors about prototypes we've failed, because failure is cool and teaches us so much; the founders will tell them about the current prototype that works and what it can do for them. If I were an investor, I know which truth I'd rather hear.
I agree, some engineers can be founders, but they generally should not be alone at the top. Likewise, any start-up will benefit from having an engineer on its management team. Engineers will ask the tough questions that need to be answered before the investors show up at the doorstep.

And, having said all that, there are exceptions -- exceptional people, that is. Tom Krol of IMET is a great engineer, and a great founder too. One day thousands will see what I see.