|
Accuracy Ron Graham with LeAnne Davis, Scott A. Hill, Doug Morgan, and Rufus Smith |
|
|
|
|
|
Most people look at accuracy and
precision
as the same thing. The difference is subtle, and
even the dictionary isn't very helpful, using
even more complex words to define both.
accuracy = the state of being correct For practical purposes, this means you shouldn't use these two words interchangeably. The above (admittedly complicated) diagram shows how engineers in some industries (e.g. aerospace and robotics) might look at the difference. In this diagram, "knowledge" represents the range between where you should be and where you think you should be -- if your knowledge is perfect, then where you should be is a single point. Or a single answer. Likewise, "precision" represents the range between where you are and where you think you are. If you're perfectly precise, with the significant digits allowed by the problem, then you are where you think you are. If both knowledge and precision are perfect, you have no "uncertainty" about your answer; the "accuracy" is just the difference between where you are and where you should be -- the degree of correctness. As if that isn't difficult enough to absorb: some answers are subject to real-time change. In some aerospace tasks they call this effect "jitter." It's hard to be accurate when the answers are moving around. :-) In some types of engineering tasks, though, there's a "budget" on accuracy -- a level of jitter you can tolerate, a level of precision you must have, a level of knowledge you can settle for. The idea with the budget is to parcel out sources of uncertainty so that one source doesn't dominate the problem. Why be precise to five significant digits to the right of a decimal point when your knowledge is only as good as integers? Here are some other (hopefully simpler) ways of looking at the difference:
Does that help? :-) Assignments You can test accuracy from a robotics point of view simply. If you have two concentric cardboard tubes, joined at three points by rubber bands, you can look through the tube to locate a target, then "grab" the target by turning one tube relative to the other, tightening the rubber bands. What affects your accuracy?
|
|