|
You can't always tell that readers aren't reading your
work unless you watch them read, but it's possible to
observe their distraction when you speak to them. No
audience is completely on your side. They're on their
own side. They're interested in what most benefits
them. And when they're lectured for somewhere around
12 to 15 minutes, on whatever subject, their eyes are
likely to begin to glaze over -- unless they get a
chance to process what they hear through discussion or
some other action that pulls them away from distractions.
Many distractions are under your control:
- they feel anonymous and uninvolved
(can you involve them?)
- they're not all interested
- they have a limited attention span when they are
interested
- they can only retain a small number of thoughts
within a single "frame of awareness" (e.g. a
viewgraph)
- they can't see your visual materials
(do you have to use materials people can't see?)
- they missed/didn't understand a new term/concept
(can you make sure they catch what's new? do you
even know in advance what will be unfamiliar?)
- they can't keep up
(why are you going so fast?)
Some distractions aren't controllable:
- they vary in experience and education
(here you have to decide to whom you're speaking
and do the best you can to take pity on the rest)
- they're distracted by their own thoughts
(all you can do is be as animated as possible)
- they're uncomfortable: sore back or butt, sleepy,
hungry, have to go to the bathroom, etc.
(all you can do is take breaks and/or serve coffee
and donuts -- but those strategies will play one
distraction against another)
- none of us know everything; we don't even know
everything there is to know about what we know
Rhetoric texts typically tell you to "know your audience."
Here's what you need to know about them:
- their background and experience in your subject
- their point of view on the subject/level of acceptance
of YOUR point of view
- their relationship(s) to you
- the extent of their sameness (e.g. land of origin,
gender, economics, age, and familiarity with your
jargon and style)
- their principles, relevant to the topic you present
- the risk associated with offending individuals
- the hope of the audience's receptivity
Generations
Your audience has generations: you present to
the first generation, which repeats or passes on what
they heard from you to the second generation, and so on.
You can only directly control your presentation to the
first generation of audience (and maybe the second).
This is what makes companies use
viewgraph forms with
complete contact information on every page. The companies
feel that as soon as you take a page out of
context they
no longer have any control of your understanding. Is
this likely to affect your approach?
Whenever you try to make a point, you initiate the
following process:
- You take a body of knowledge contained
in your brain and model it. You have
to condense and simplify this knowledge for the
model to be of any use. How you simplify depends on
- your perception of your audience,
- your prioritizing of bits of information,
- the complexity of the information,
- your ability to retrieve it, and
- how you feel.
- You communicate the model to an audience
via words, symbols, images, numbers, equations,
demonstrations, etc.
- The audience receives your communication.
- The audience reverse-engineers the communicated
information to models of its own.
- Members of the audience merge their models
with previous knowledge, experience, level of
understanding, perception of context, and how they feel.
What will be the outcome? Just about any outcome is
possible, depending on the size of the audience. Some
of this process is completely uncontrollable. Consider:
- Information is sure to be lost between
communication and reception under the
best of conditions. Neither you nor the audience
will know what is lost or when it happened,
unless you can figure it out from the outcome.
- Even when you know your audience well, you
are not likely to know specific members of the
audience well, or to be able to address
them specifically.
- You have to guess how well the audience
understands what you're saying. And you
have to guess before you say it.
You can't change the audience. And you can't control most
of the process. All you can do is constrain those parts
of the process over which you have control: the modeling
and communication of information and the assessment of the
audience. The writing and speaking are the tip of the
iceberg. Your tools are
- the strength of your argument
- your confidence
- the depth and breadth of your knowledge and
preparation
- your backup materials
- your ability to communicate what it is you want
- your recognition of other views, and of your own
biases
- your credibility
- your ability to keep the audience focused
- your ability to find common ground
References
Korpela, J. "How
all human communication fails, except by accident."
http://www.hut.fi/u/jkorpela/wiio.html
Johnson, R., D. Johnson, and K. Smith. "Cooperative Learning:
An Active Learning Strategy for the College Classroom."
Baylor Educator, Winter 1990.
|